

I managed to finish two new YA novels recently:
My Mother the Cheerleader by Robert Sharenow and
Eclipse by Stephenie Meyer.
Readers captivated by Meyer's riveting saga of vampire romance will definitely enjoy the latest book in her
Twilight series. The first book introduced us to teenager Bella Swan and the mysterious Cullen family, a clan of beautiful "vegetarian" vampires who have chosen to abstain from human blood and to co-exist with them in Forks, a small hamlet among the rain-soaked woods of Washington state. Bella falls in love with Edward Cullen who seems to somehow be part of her destiny. The second book,
New Moon, pulled Bella and Edward apart, tested their love, and introduced us to shape-shifting Native American Jacob Black and the age-old prejudices between vampires and werewolves. It also left readers hanging with a decision Bella was to make concerning her immortality: Will it happen, and if so, when?
Eclipse is more of the same, but it is also different. We return to the town of Forks and find that graduation is looming (after which, the Cullens have agreed to make Bella a vampire). Even though it's her senior year, the whole high school issue is basically glossed over, with very little of the plot revolving around her school days in this book. There's a serial killer on the loose in nearby Seattle, so trips into the city are out of the question. And Bella cannot visit Jacob, her steadfast best friend, because he is a werewolf. Due to her ties to the vampires, it would break treaties and bonds made between them centuries before. The sometimes over-long book (629 pages) spends a fair amount of time covering the Quileute Indian backstory of Jake's werewolf heritage. Lots of stories, not a lot of action. There's plenty of macho posturing by both Edward and Jake to win Bella's attention, and their behavior on her behalf makes Bella seem more of a spoiled brat by comparison. It isn't often that a writer makes her main character so unlikeable as Meyer does Bella, but it happens several times in
Eclipse, or at least it did with me anyway. On the other hand, Meyer's use of humor sprinkled throughout the book was a welcome surprise, and I found myself grinning at some of the darker jokes.
As the days go by, and graduation gets closer, Bella must choose her fate. She wants to become immortal and be with Edward, but she must give up her family to do so. She is also worried about the change: will she be able to focus like the Cullen family and refrain from human blood? Or will her new vampire lust cause her to kill innocent people? How will her new life (after-death) affect relationships with her family and friends? Bella finally starts asking mature questions that need serious examination, then in a quick turnabout, behaves like a pouty little tease as she tries to seduce Edward before their agreed upon first time. The irony here is that the vampire is the one with morals. He insists they wait until they are married.
The serial killings in Seattle continue and turn out to be supernatural in origin: they were all victims of an army of newborn vampires created specifically to attack the Cullen's peaceful forest enclave. The city killings have been a training exercise for an upcoming battle of revenge against Edward and his family. This brings up even more issues for Bella and her decision to become immortal. Not that anything could ever persuade her to give Edward up (stubbornness in my opinion is a character flaw, not an attribute), but it makes the choice more difficult by showing her the realities of becoming a vampire.
Without revealing too much plot, Jacob has also decided he wants more from Bella, which makes her decision even more difficult. Must Bella choose between the love of her life and her devoted best friend? In a recent interview, the author said that if the first book was about finding love, and the second book was about losing love, then the third book is about choosing love. How do we decide who we are going to spend the rest of our life with? Is it better to get to know someone as a friend first, then let things eventually turn into love? Is there truly a "soulmate" out there for everyone? What if your soulmate turns out not to have a soul? Whichever one she chooses, how will the other react to her decision? These are just a few of the questions tormenting Bella as she prepares for high school graduation and what the next phase of life holds for her. Guess we'll have to wait until the 4th book,
Breaking Dawn, comes out sometime in 2008 to see exactly what that is.
The second book I read this week was also about racism, but not the imaginary kind between werewolves and vampires. It was about a real incident that happened during one of the pivotal events of America's Civil Rights Movement. In
My Mother the Cheerleader, author Robert Sharenow tells a fictional story of one family's experience with forced integration in a New Orleans elementary school in November 1960. A little black girl named Ruby Bridges is being escorted to class by armed guards through a crowd of white supremacists, bigots, and racists, all chanting hateful messages and calling her names. Witness to the event is 13-year-old Louise Collins, who lives with her mother in their boardinghouse in the town's Ninth Ward. Louise, like most of the other white children, has been pulled from the school because of all the prejudice and unrest. Not willing to sit idly in her room with all this excitement going on, Louise sneaks off on a spy mission to see for herself what is happening at the school. There she finds her own mother among the so-called "Cheerleaders," a group of white housewives chanting and hurling insults at the innocent little black girl. The issue gains national attention, and before long, a stranger appears on their doorstep wanting to rent a room. He is charming and intellectual, but these qualities are overshadowed by his mysterious past. The man's visit eventually becomes suspicious, and soon everything Louise thinks she knows about her mother, herself, and her world changes forever.
This book has been receiving a lot of positive press from the literary world, but I am sure there are plenty of people who will take issue with it soon enough. First off, I have a problem with the title and the cover art. Neither gives potential readers any indication of what the book is going to be about. There's also the issue that the mother is a drunk and a part-time prostitute, and the fact that a fair share of swear words, not to mention the "N-word", is used freely. Of course, I suppose it would be difficult to write about racial hatred during the early days of the Civil Rights Movement and
not use that word, but still... Does this story need to be told? Yes. Could it have been told better? That's for each individual to decide.
I recommend both of these books for mature readers, preferably 8th grade and above.